When Ed Miliband first announced a cap on energy prices before the 2015 election the Tories denounced it as a ridiculous attempt to buck the market, an exercise in socialist economic control and a sure sign that the nation was going “back to the seventies”. Now, spooked by Jeremy Corbyn’s boundless campaigning energy, they’ve shamelessly copied the idea. Well, the Tories were right first time: it is a futile and indeed damaging policy. Here’s why.
First, you can’t buck the market. Somewhere, somehow, the energy companies will find a way to structure tariffs to get their revenues back. That, in fact, is what, as businesses supposed to generate a profit, they are supposed to do. The simplest way would be to reduce the appeal of all those special offer “teaser” rates they offer new customers and switchers. So there’ll be a net effect of transferring money from the more sassy and discriminating consumer to those who are too ignorant or lazy to shop around. Is that right and just?
Photographs of missing Syrians are displayed as people, including a group of Syrian women, stand atop a double-decker bus during a demonstration by ‘Families for Freedom’ in Parliament Square in London
Workmen erect scaffolding around the Elizabeth Tower, commonly known called Big Ben, during ongoing renovations to the Tower and the Houses of Parliament
An order of service is carried ahead of the funeral service for Coronation Street actress Liz Dawn, real name Sylvia Ann Ibbetson, outside Salford Cathedral. A former Woolworths shop girl from Leeds, who first set foot on Weatherfield’s famous cobbles in 1974, Dawn, who had four children, died peacefully last week at home with her family around her.
Melanie Kramers of Oxfam poses while wearing a mask of Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson, with assorted props used in political campaigns, in the store room at Oxfam’s headquarters in London. The props have all been used in the charity’s campaigns over the years to raise awareness of issues affecting people in poverty. Today marks 75 years since Oxfam’s founding in the middle of the Second World War
A visitor poses in front of an art work by Czech Repblic artist Anna Hulacova entitled ‘Ascension Mark I’ during a photocall for the Frieze Art Fair in London
Britain’s Chancellor of the Exchequer Philip Hammond arrives to speak at the Conservative Party’s conference in Manchester
Protesters holding flags and placards demonstrate along Oxford Street during the annual Ashura march in London. Thousands of protesters march through London today to mark Ashura and celebrate the defeat of the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria. Ashura is a Muslim festival of remembrance that falls on the tenth day of Muharram in the Islamic calendar
Protesters hold up placards during the London March for Choice, calling for the legalising of abortion in Ireland after the referendum announcement, outside the Embassy of Ireland in central London
Chris J Ratcliffe/AFP
Former UKIP leader Paul Nuttall (C) speaks with delegates at the UKIP annual conference being held at the The Riviera International Centre in Torquay
England and West Indies fans enjoy themselves during the 4th Royal London One Day International between England and West Indies at The Kia Oval in London
Labour Leader Jeremy Corbyn takes photographs during Shadow Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy Rebecca Long-Bailey’s speech in the main hall, on day three of the annual Labour Party Conference in Brighton
Dan Kitwood/Getty Images
Naked bathers enter the water as they take part in the North East Skinny Dip at Druridge bay in Druridge, England. The popular annual event takes place around the autumn equinox at Druridge Bay as the sun rises. Participant registration fees have been pledged to the mental health charity MIND.
Rollo Maughfling, Archdruid of Stonehenge and Britain (R) conducts a ceremony as druids, pagans and revellers gather in the centre at Stonehenge, hoping to see the sun rise, as they take part in a autumn equinox celebrations at the ancient neolithic monument of Stonehenge near Amesbury in Wiltshire, England. Several hundred people gathered at sunrise ar the famous historic stone circle, a UNESCO listed ancient monument, to celebrate the equinox which is a specific moment in time that occurs twice a year when the Earth tilts neither towards (summer) or away (winter) from the sun in either the northern or southern hemisphere. Although yesterday marked the actual meteorological calendar change from summer to autumn, for druids, the following dawn is when they celebrate ‘the dawning of the new season’ following the day of equal night, which it is named after.
Britain’s Prime Minister Theresa May delivers her Brexit speech at the Complesso Santa Maria Novella in Florence, Italy. British Prime Minister Theresa May will seek to unlock Brexit talks on September 22, after Brussels demanded more clarity on the crunch issues of budget payments and EU citizens’ rights
People protest against the actions of the Spanish government in front of the Spanish consulate in Edinburgh. Spanish police stormed ministries and buildings belonging to Catalonia’s regional government yesterday, in an attempt to try and put a stop to the region’s independence referendum
One of the final 55m turbine blades is manoeuvred into position. The last of 116 wind turbines have been installed at the Rampion Offshore Wind Farm 13 kms off the Brighton Coast. It will provide enough electricity to supply the equivalent of half the homes in Sussex
Mike Hewitt/Getty Images
An armed police officer patrols in Horse Guards Parade in London. An 18-year-old man has been arrested in Dover in connection with yesterday’s terror attack on Parsons Green station in which 30 people were injured. The UK terror threat level has been raised to ‘critical’
Jack Taylor/Getty Images
Demonstrators hold banners during a protest to lobby MPs to guarantee the rights of EU citizens living in the UK, after Brexit, outside the Houses of Parliament
Rupert van der Werff, Summer Place Auctions’ Natural History specialist, moves a one-year-old baby mammoth skeleton at Summers Place Auctions on September 12, 2017 in Billingshurst. A family of four mammoths, found together during building works near the Siberian city of Tomsk in 2002, will be on sale on November 21, 2017, and are expected to sell in the region of £ 250,000 – 400,000
Rob Stothard/Getty Images
Members of the Royal Navy carry supplies on board the amphibious assault ship HMS Ocean at the Naval Base in Gibraltar before leaving to provide humanitarian assistance and vital aid to British Overseas Territories and Commonwealth partners affected by Hurricane Irma. Britain has pledged £32 million (35 million euros, $42 million) in aid and sent hundreds of troops, supplies and rescue equipment on several flights to the British territories in the Caribbean since the disaster
JORGE GUERRERO/AFP/Getty Images
His Holiness The Dalai Lama holds the hand of Richard Moore as he gives a public talk on the theme of ‘Compassion in Action’ to celebrate 20 years of the Children in Crossfire initiative in Londonderry, Northern Ireland. The Dalai Lama is the patron of the Children in Crossfire charity which was founded by Richard Moore. Mr Moore was blinded by a plastic bullet fired by a British Soldier during the Troubles in Derry.
Participants in the annual Jane Austen Regency Costumed Parade dance on the lawn of the historic Georgian Royal Crescent before they walk through the city centre in Bath, England. This year, the annual event coincided with the 200th anniversary of 19th century author’s death and saw hundreds of people parade through city centre streets dressed in regency costume. The event marks the start of a 10-day Jane Austen festival that celebrates the 19th century author who lived in the city from 1801 to 1806 and set two of her six published novels, ‘Northanger Abbey’ and ‘Persuasion’, in Bath.
Festival goers brave the wind and the rain at Bestival festival on the Lulworth Estate in Dorset
Matt Cardy/Getty Images
Conservators and museum staff pose as they inspect the Manchester suffragette banner hanging in the conservation department of Manchester People’s History Museum. For nearly 50 years the banner lay undiscovered in a Leeds charity shop. It will go on public display next year to mark the centenary of women gaining the vote
Christopher Furlong/Getty Images
Protesters wave placards in Parliament Square during a protest against a Government pay cap in London. Thousands of protesters made up of nurses and supporters hold a demonstration in Westminster today calling on the Government to end the 1% cap on public sector pay
Jack Taylor/Getty Images
U Soe Win, the great-grandson of Burma’s last King, visits Buckingham Palace
John Phillips/Getty Images
Protestors demonstrate in support of workers at British McDonalds restaurants striking over pay and other industrial relations issues, near the Houses of Parliament in London
World War II veteran from the Auxiliary Territorial Service Betty Webb (R) joins other veterans who worked at Bletchley Park and its outstations for a group picture in front of Bletchley Park Mansion during an annual reunion in Milton Keynes, England. Bletchley Park was the Government Code and Cypher School’s (GC&CS) main codebreaking centre during World War II and the site where codebreakers famously cracked the German’s Enigma and Lorenz cyphers.
50,000 people making the foot crossing over new Queensferry road bridge
Britain’s Prime Minister, Theresa May, is greeted by Emperor Akihito of Japan during her visit to the Royal Palace in Tokyo, Japan. Mrs May is on the third and final day of her visit to Japan where she has discussed a number of issues including trade and security
Carl Court/Getty Images
Well-wishers and Royal ‘enthusiasts’ gather outside the gates of Kensington Palace where tributes continue to be left, on the 20th anniversary of the death of Princess Diana
Dan Kitwood/Getty Images
Prime Minister Theresa May takes part in a tea ceremony in Kyoto, during her visit to Japan.
Second, energy companies are not some sort of diabolical agents of evil. They’re private companies in the business of supplying and/or generating gas and electricity and supplying it to businesses and homes. They are regulated. There is competition between the “Big Six”. The market isn’t “broken”. You can shop around. There are price comparison sites to help you switch. There is even competition between price comparison sites. There are “cashback” companies that will give you cash to switch on top of the savings you’ll make on your bills. Competition is there, and is more intense than ever before – and especially when there was just one body in the country supplying gas, British Gas, and electricity was also a state monopoly.
And, by the way, I cannot see why anyone takes pride in being a “loyal customer” of SSE or E.On: loyalty to your partner or family or friends is one thing, but an energy utility? Don’t be draft.
More to the point, energy companies need to generate profits. They have to, like all firms, reward shareholders for supplying the equity capital they need, and banks and bond holders for the money they have lent to the utilities to build infrastructure such as wind farms, invest in new power sources and storage, and so on. Profit is not a dirty word. Profits are needed for investment. Restrict prices and you restrict revenues and you restrict profits and you restrict investment. In the long run that means less capacity and poorer infrastructure – and more chance of power cuts and brownouts. Is that what we really desire?
Third: the green argument. If, for whatever reason, you reduce energy costs then people will use more. So we will burn more fossil fuels and have less chance of hitting our CO2 targets and saving the planet. A prime example of the law of unintended consequences.
Four: it is a very bad way to help the poor. I’d agree that the old and poor tend to stick on the standard variable rate, and that their lack of access to the internet and acquaintance with price comparison sites has hindered them, but that goes for everything. Simply cap tariffs and you will also help the rich who are so loaded they don’t even notice their gas and electric bills. Inefficient.
There are much better ways to deal with fuel poverty – the winter fuel allowance for pensioners being one rather crude but obvious example. Improve benefits and the old age pension, and allow people to make their own decisions. That, though, would mean persuading working, middle class, middle England to stump up, rather than send the bill to some of the mythical panto villains of the leccy market. No one wants to pay more taxes, I’m afraid, which is the honest way to redistribute income.
The policy of capping tariffs makes no economic sense at all. Not so long ago, the Conservatives seemed to have the intellectual confidence to make the argument for private enterprise, and mock and defeat the idea. Now they don’t have the guts to take on the arguments. So dismal is it that they lack the intellectual capacity to do so. They are instead engaged in an exercise of trying to out-Corbyn Jeremy Corbyn, and that’s a contest they can never win. All they are doing is lending the notion of the state control of prices some kind of respectability.
What will they cap next? Petrol? Butter? Broadband? Whatever happened to the party that told people to take responsibility for their own welfare? What planet is Theresa May on? Planet Venezuela, perhaps.Reuse content